The Madden 2010 Player Ratings for the Arizona Cardinals came out today. Time to see if the good folks at EA got the ratings right. I will do my best not to be bias. I will only touch on relevant players, because honestly I don’t think anyone cares what Brian St. Pierre rating is.
QB Kurt Warner 94
They have Warner rated perfectly here. His return to grace last season makes him a top tier QB, but anything above this rating would probably have been a little too much. Fire up Madden 2010 and party like its 1999 again, probably the last time Warner had a rating so high.
QB Matt Leinart 68
Ouch, Matt Leinart sits out a year and his rating drastically declines. Maybe the good people at EA took offense to his beer bong photos of last off-season, but that was almost a year ago. I would have rated Leinart in the mid 70s.
RB Chris Wells 79
In all my years of playing Madden I have learned one thing: First round draft picks are always going to fall in the 77-83 range. Wells my be a huge find and rush for 1,500+ yards this year but he has to start where every other rookie did, with a rating in the seventies.
RB Tim Hightower 75
Sure, Tim Hightower wasn’t the most spectacular runner last year but I have to think this rating was a little low. For his goal line abilities and toughness I would have rated him at an 80.
WR Larry Fitzgerald 99
There is no way Fitz could have been anything less than a 99 after his performance in the playoffs last year. The only beef I could possibly have with EA is that they didn’t give him the first ever 100 overall rating this year.
WR Anquan Boldin 94
I think this is a little high for Boldin. I would have slotted him at 90, but maybe I am just bitter about the whole contract situation. I believe this is the highest rating Boldin has had in a Madden game, but don’t quote me on that.
WR Steve Breaston 79
Really EA? Breaston’s season last year warranted an 85 overall rating this year. He easily filled in for Boldin when he had to and was a dangerous third receiver. Steve is getting totally screwed by the rating system here.
OL Mike Gandy 86
Sure
OL Levi Brown 81
If you’re gonna make Gandy an 86 might as well make Levi Brown an 86.
DT Darnell Dockett 94
I still have visions in my head of Dockett destroying the Steelers‘ offensive line in the Super Bowl, which makes me want to say he should be rated higher. In reality, 94 is probably the right rating for Dockett.
DE Bert Berry 83
I’m fine with this rating, but will this be the year EA finally lists him as an OLB, the position he has played for the past two seasons? Probably not.
DE Chike Okeafor 76
I would have put Chikie a little higher, but I doubt anyone is complaining that he is a 76.
DE Calais Campbell 74
He didn’t do a whole lot last year to justify a bigger rating, but I think he will preform well above a 74 level on the field this year.
LB Karlos Dansby 89
Dansby should be a 90, it’s that simple.
CB Dominque Rodgers-Cromartie 87
I love DRC so I am going to be totally bias here and say he should be a 90. A 87 is probably good for him, as long as he has 99 speed.
CB Bryant McFadden 78
Did Bryant do something to piss off EA? His rating is much, much lower than I would have guessed. I considered McFadden a mid 80s guy, low 80s at the worst. I might have to fire up the player editor when I get my copy and change this injustice.
S Adrian Wilson 97
EA has always given Adrian ratings love. Is he a 97 overall? I would have guessed a low 90s rating for him.
S Antrel Rolle 84
This one really surprised me, I would have guessed EA would give Rolle a high 70s rating. I would have personally given him an 80, so I think this rating is a tad high.
K Neil Rackers 81
Cardinals fans will be pissed, but does it really matter what your kicker is rated? I needed a clutch field gaol in about 0.05% of all the Madden games I have ever played.
I did that once…but it involved whiskey.